Noma’s victory at
the S. Pellegrino World’s 50 Best Restaurants last night is a triumph
both for the Copenhagen eatery and for the awards, which were stuck in a
rut, handing out first place each year to El Bulli.

Danish chef Rene Redzepi was there to collect the crown that had gone for the past four years to Ferran Adria for his establishment north of Barcelona. El Bulli has been in the top three every year since the awards were founded in 2002.
Heston Blumenthal’s Fat Duck has been the other big winner,
coming first in 2005 and always making the top three since 2004. The
U.K. restaurant came third last night, behind El Bulli. The only other
winner has been the French Laundry, in 2003 and 2004. Noma, which seats
42 diners, was founded in November 2003.
The S. Pellegrino World’s 50 Best Restaurants were named at a reception
in London’s Guildhall attended by chefs and restaurateurs including Daniel Boulud,
whose New York flagship surged 33 places to No. 8. The awards started
as a magazine feature and have grown to international prominence.

Noma -- which stands for Nordisk Mad, or Nordic Food -- is housed in a
converted warehouse by the waterside in the Danish capital’s
Christianshavn district. Redzepi, 32, travels the region in search of
ingredients and culinary inspiration for his seasonal menu. Noma entered
the table at 33 in 2006 and had risen to third by last year.
“When I first got an invitation saying, ‘Congratulations, you are now on the 50 Best Restaurants list,’ I’d never really heard about it,” Redzepi said in an interview at Noma in February. “But immediately after the award show, you realized it was something special by the press coverage, the phone calls.
‘Turning Point’
“From there on, our restaurant really started to take off. It was
like a turning point being on that list. So it went from something that
perhaps I didn’t acknowledge in the way that I should to something
that’s been crucial for us.”
El Celler de Can Roca and Mugaritz, both in Spain, took fourth and fifth
places. The highest U.S. entry was Alinea, of Chicago, in seventh
place. New York restaurants Daniel, Per Se and Le Bernardin, took
eighth, 10th and 15th, respectively.

The London winners were St. John, at 43, and Hibiscus, at 49. Adria was
chef of the decade, and the chefs’ choice award went to the Fat Duck. La
Colombe, Cape Town, was top in Africa and the Middle East; D.O.M. of
Sao Paulo came first in Latin America; and Les Creations de Narisawa,
Tokyo, topped Asia.
Ramsay, Wareing
Gordon Ramsay failed to make the top 100 for the second straight year. The British chef’s former associate, Marcus Wareing, came 58th with his restaurant at the Berkeley.
The winners are picked by more than 800 chefs, food writers and
restaurateurs from around the world. I’m a member of the U.K. panel and
each of us votes confidentially, without meeting -- or even necessarily
knowing the identity of -- the other panelists. The U.K. and Ireland
panel is headed by Jay Rayner.
Members of the voting academy are required to have eaten in the
restaurants we nominate within the previous 18 months and we have to
vote for at least two places outside our own region.
Everyone knows the list is imperfect. Asia is historically
underrepresented, while the Top 10 includes four restaurants in Spain
and not a single one in France. There’s no controlling hand behind the
World’s 50 Best and -- even though I’m a voter -- I’ve found myself
checking the names of places in Russia, Slovenia and Croatia that have
made the Top 100 this year.
The awards started in 2002 as a feature in “Restaurant,” a U.K. publication founded the previous year. The writer Joe Warwick
said he sent e-mails to journalists and chefs to pick their favorite
places, like a music magazine naming best albums. That first year,
British venues did suspiciously well: Gordon Ramsay came second and the
Ivy took eighth place. El Bulli won.
Academy Idea
“The next year, we did a little event and, lo and behold, Ferran Adria
showed up,” said Warwick, who went on to become the magazine’s editor.
“I thought: Hang on, we’d better do this properly, so we came up with
the idea of the academy.
“Nobody had done this before, and we got a lot of stick for it. But
people love lists and the thing took off. People ask me now: Best for
what? Well, we never defined that.”
At the center of Redzepi’s cuisine are fine, seasonal Nordic
ingredients: halibut, wild salmon, seaweed and curds from Iceland; lamb,
musk ox, berries and the purest drinking water from Greenland,
according to Noma’s Web site. While the style is modern -- Redzepi’s
resume includes El Bulli and the French Laundry -- the focus is on the
produce, not the technique.
Tasting Menu
When I ate there in February, the seven-course tasting menu cost 995
kroner ($180) plus service; matching wines were 895 kroner, or juices
395 kroner; there was a 595 kroner lunch menu.
There were six different types of canape, including pickled quail eggs
smoked on a bed of hay, and smoked cod roe on toast with vinegar. That’s
before we got onto the 10-course meal, which included squid and lingon
berries, cream and dill; sour grape juice from the isle of Lilleo,
caramelized onions and thyme leaves; beef cheek and pickled flowers and
winter cabbage.